Commuted value or monthly pension when you leave an employer

Leaving a job after years in a defined benefit pension plan usually comes with a package of paper and a decision. The pension you have earned can stay in the plan and be paid as a monthly income later, or its present-day value can be moved out as a lump sum. The lump sum is called the commuted value, and for long-serving members it can be the largest single figure they have ever seen with their name on it.

This file explains what that figure represents, where it can go, and the tax limit that often splits it in two. It does not recommend either path. The right answer depends on health, other income, a spouse’s needs and appetite for investment risk, which no general article can weigh.

The choice that arrives with the exit papers

When employment ends before the member is eligible to retire under the plan, the administrator sets out the options in writing, with a deadline to choose. In many plans, saying nothing means the pension stays in the plan as a deferred pension. Choosing a transfer requires a signed election.

The deadline matters, because commuted values are recalculated as time passes and as interest rates move. A figure in a statement is a value at a date, not a price that holds indefinitely.

What a commuted value is

The federal pension regulator, OSFI, defines a commuted value as the amount of an immediate lump-sum payment estimated to be equal in value to a future series of payments. In plain terms, it is what the plan calculates it would need today to fund the pension it has promised you from retirement onwards.

Because it is a present value, it depends heavily on the interest rates used in the calculation. When rates are low, more money is needed today to fund the same future pension, so commuted values rise; when rates are higher, they fall. The pension itself does not change. Only its price today does.

The usual options on leaving

Ontario’s regulator, FSRA, summarises the options for a member who leaves before early retirement eligibility. In most provinces and in federally regulated plans they are similar:

• Leave it in the plan as a deferred pension, payable from the plan’s retirement age.
• Transfer the commuted value to a new employer’s plan, if that plan accepts transfers.
• Transfer it to a locked-in account, such as a locked-in retirement account (LIRA) or a life income fund (LIF), subject to conditions.
• Use it to buy a life annuity from an insurance company.

Transfers stay locked in: the money must still be used to provide retirement income and cannot simply be withdrawn. What a locked-in account becomes later is explained in what a locked-in account turns into at retirement. Very small pensions are treated differently, and may be paid out in cash or to an RRSP.

The tax limit on the transfer

This is the part most people meet for the first time. The Income Tax Regulations cap how much of a commuted value can move tax-deferred from a defined benefit plan to a locked-in account or RRSP. The cap, under section 8517, is the annual lifetime pension being commuted multiplied by a present value factor based on age at the time of transfer.

The factor is 9.0 for anyone under 50, rises to 9.4 at 50 and 11.5 at 60, and peaks at 12.4 at 64 and 65 before declining. Anything above the cap cannot be transferred tax-free. The Canada Revenue Agency’s technical guidance says the excess must be paid in cash and is included in income for the year it is received. Someone with unused RRSP deduction room can usually contribute part or all of that cash to an RRSP and deduct it, which softens the tax; someone without room cannot.

An illustrative transfer

The figures below are hypothetical and chosen only to show how the cap works. Real commuted values come from the plan’s actuarial calculation.

Two things stand out. First, more than a quarter of this hypothetical commuted value cannot stay sheltered. Second, the taxable part lands in a single year, often the same year as a final salary or severance, which can push it into a high bracket. The timing of the exit and of RRSP room can matter as much as the headline figure.

What each path keeps and gives up

FSRA’s guidance puts the trade-off in one sentence: transferring means giving up the right to a monthly pension payable for life, along with other plan benefits such as survivor benefits, and the decision is irreversible. The broader difference between a promised pension and an invested account is covered in defined benefit and defined contribution pensions are not the same promise.

What to ask before signing

Survivor rights deserve their own attention, because they are protected by law in most provinces; see how the survivor option changes the monthly amount.

The short version

A commuted value is the price today of a pension promised for later. Taking it moves the investment and longevity risk from the plan to you, and part of it may be paid as taxable cash because of the age-based limit in the tax rules. Leaving it in the plan keeps a defined income and the plan’s survivor benefits. Both are legitimate choices; only one of them can be reversed.

SOURCES ON FILE

1. OSFI — Glossary of pension plan terms — definition of commuted value and locked-in.
2. FSRA — Member guide: you terminated employment, what is a commuted value? — options on leaving, locking-in, irreversibility.
3. Income Tax Regulations, section 8517 — prescribed transfer amount and present value factors by age.
4. Canada Revenue Agency — Registered Plans Directorate technical manual, chapter 20 (8517) — excess over the limit paid in cash and included in income.

THE FRIDAY FILE / WEEKLY / FREE

The Friday File. One source of retirement income, explained on a single page.

Every Friday: one rule, one date or one number worth checking on CPP, workplace pensions, RRSPs, RRIFs or the tax on them. Free, and you can unsubscribe from any issue.

Your email address Sign me up

Send me The Friday File. I have read the privacy notice. I will first receive one email asking me to confirm my address; nothing else is sent until I confirm.